CC
CARNIVAL CORP (CCL)·Q4 2020 Earnings Summary
Executive Summary
- Q4 2020 reflected continued zero/near-zero revenue operations with U.S. GAAP net loss of $2.22B and adjusted net loss of $1.86B; cash burn averaged $500M/month, better than plan due to CapEx timing .
- Liquidity strengthened: year-end cash was $9.5B after raising $4.5B in late-Q4 (ATMs: $2.5B; unsecured notes: $2.0B); cumulative capital raised since March reached $19B .
- Demand indicators improved: H2 2021 bookings within historical range and H1 2022 ahead of 2019; ~60% of Q4 bookings for FY2021 were new bookings (not FCC rebookings) .
- Near-term guidance: Q1 2021 cash burn expected to rise to ~$600M/month due to restart expenditures and shifted CapEx; company expects net loss in Q1 and FY2021 and cannot provide an earnings forecast .
What Went Well and What Went Wrong
What Went Well
- Bookings momentum and quality: “Cumulative advanced bookings for the first half of 2022 are ahead of 2019,” achieved with minimal advertising; comparable pricing down ~1% ex-FCCs with bundled packages expected to lift onboard revenue .
- Liquidity actions: $9.5B year-end cash and $4.5B raised in late Q4; early conversion of $1.5B converts and optimized capital structure; “liquidity in place to sustain throughout 2021, even in a zero-revenue environment” .
- Fleet optimization: accelerated removal of 19 less efficient ships (15 exited), reducing base cost by ~2% per ALBD and fuel ~1% per ALBD, improving future margins; only one delivery in FY2021 vs five originally .
What Went Wrong
- Continued operational pause: company unable to predict full-fleet resumption; expects net losses in Q1 and FY2021 and cannot provide earnings forecast .
- Elevated interest burden: interest expense on existing debt
$130M/month ($1.6B annualized), limiting near-term earnings power until operations ramp and refinancing proceeds . - Cyber/security exposure: IT security incident affecting two brands disclosed, with preliminary view that impact is not material; still a risk factor highlighted .
Financial Results
Loss and Liquidity Overview (oldest → newest)
Notes: EPS not disclosed in Q3/Q4 preliminary 8-Ks; company furnished net loss and adjusted net loss. Q4 cash burn improved due to CapEx timing .
Revenue (reported)
Balance Sheet/Capitalization Highlights
KPIs
Guidance Changes
Earnings Call Themes & Trends
Management Commentary
- CEO (Arnold Donald): “With the aggressive actions we have taken, managing the balance sheet and reducing capacity, we are well positioned to capitalize on pent up demand and to emerge a leaner, more efficient company” .
- CFO (David Bernstein) on bookings/pricing: cumulative advanced bookings for H2 2021 within historical range; H1 2022 ahead of strong 2019; pricing down ~1% ex-FCCs; bundles make comparison “more favorable than indicated” and will benefit onboard/other revenue .
- CFO on liquidity/cash burn: Q4 cash burn ~$500M/month (better than $530M expected) due to CapEx timing; Q1 cash burn ~ $600M including restart expenses and more dry dock days; year-end cash $9.5B .
- CFO on capital structure: ~$19B raised since the pause; ability to issue more debt if needed; will optimize liabilities and refinance at lower rates where possible .
- CEO on CDC/test cruises: awaiting further technical guidance; “we want the freedom to operate,” with global footprint providing flexibility .
Key quotes:
- “We ended the year with $9.5 billion in cash and have the liquidity in place to sustain ourselves throughout 2021, even in a zero-revenue environment” .
- Interest expense: “about $130 million a month or… $1.6 billion for the year” .
- Share count: “outstanding… at the end of 2020 was 1.087 billion… conversion of the remaining converts… 1.14 billion” .
Q&A Highlights
- Liquidity vs ramp timing: Management retains optionality to raise debt depending on restart timing uncertainty; aim to refinance and opportunistically enhance liquidity .
- Vaccines and policy: Monitoring global guidance; distribution/logistics still evolving; policies to be set prudently with authorities .
- Restart costs: Crew return/testing/provisioning; per-ship protocol costs a few hundred thousand euros/month in Europe; U.S. costs depend on pending CDC specifics .
- Pricing/bundles: Bundled offerings allocated to onboard/other revenue; headline pricing down ~1% ex-FCCs but apples-to-oranges; expect onboard revenue uplift .
- Structural efficiencies: Ship exits reduce base costs (~2% per ALBD) and fuel (~1% per ALBD); shore-side efficiencies ongoing .
- Debt, capex and deliveries: Debt $27B at 11/30/20; +~$1.5B in December export credit draws; no cancellation clauses in newbuild contracts; 2022 capacity ~+5.6% vs 2019 in ALBDs with net low growth due to exits .
Estimates Context
- S&P Global consensus estimates for Q4 2020 EPS and revenue were unavailable at the time of analysis due to data access limits. As such, we cannot quantify beats/misses versus Wall Street consensus for Q4 2020 at this time.
- We will update beats/misses when S&P Global data becomes available.
Key Takeaways for Investors
- Demand resilience remains intact: H1 2022 bookings ahead of 2019 despite minimal marketing; mix of new-to-brand (~45%) and new bookings (~60% of FY2021 Q4 bookings) supports recovery trajectory .
- Liquidity runway is robust: $9.5B cash at year-end; ability and intent to optimize/refinance liabilities; near-term interest burden ~$1.6B annually until operations ramp/refinance progresses .
- Structural margin upside post-resumption: Fleet exits and newer deliveries reduce cost base and fuel intensity; shore-side efficiency initiatives should enhance EBITDA margins as revenues normalize .
- Near-term cash burn uptick a function of restart prep, not weaker fundamentals: Q1 burn guide ~$600M vs Q4 $500M reflects CapEx timing and dry docks; monitor restart cadence and CDC’s technical guidance .
- Balance sheet watch items: Debt maturities staggered through FY2021; continued capital markets access provides flexibility; interest and depreciation disclosures frame P&L headwinds near term .
- Trading lens: Stock likely reactive to regulatory milestones (CDC guidance/test cruise timing) and visible U.S./international restart dates; booking updates and liquidity actions are catalysts for sentiment .
Appendix: Additional Q4 2020 Disclosures
- Debt maturity schedule FY2021: Q1 $0.5B; Q2 $0.4B; Q3 $0.7B; Q4 $0.3B (ex revolver; $3.0B drawn, maturing through March 2021) .
- Bookings/book position detail: ~45% of affected guests took enhanced FCCs; ~55% refunds; deposits declined modestly to $2.2B (from $2.4B) .
- Health & safety protocols: Advisors engaged; Costa earned RINA Biosafety Trust Certification; protocols updated per evolving science; U.S. resumption based on CDC framework .
Citations:
All figures and statements are sourced from CCL’s Q4 2020 8-K/business update and Q4 2020 earnings call transcript: , and Q&A transcript -. Prior quarter trends from Q3 and Q2 2020 8-Ks: .